For anyone who has been to an event where the Dalai Lama is the main speaker, just looking around at the audience, it soon becomes obvious that he draws people from all religions, including even atheists. Young and old, it doesn’t matter. So what is going on?
My hunch is that Tibetan Buddhism has come to represent spirituality, not religion. The modern world is starting to become keenly interested in spirituality. By comparison, it understands religion to be inadequate which its sees as being often too creedal (= I believe), sectarian (e.g., fundamentalism), dogmatic and superficial. This is not so with spirituality which asks us to look within, for example, by first being aware of our internal dialogue.
If spirituality can be represented by just a few words they are look within. But this looking within is not about finding silence within us or coming to know God. Far from it. This looking is about what is most primordial in us trying to recognize itself and in so doing awaken to the basis or substance of all phenomena which then renders phenomena to be illusory and unreal so that we are no longer bewitched by it. Short of this, we doom ourselves to wander (samsara) passing from one false existence to another having believed this was truth or the best of all possible worlds.
For those who are somewhat familiar with Tibetan Buddhism its higher teachings are certainly spiritual but to get to a point where one can proficiently look within the individual has to be gradually weaned off of religion the practice of which can easily become perfunctory and ritualistic. The weaning process is by no means an easy one. While there are many people who yearn to practice a genuine spiritual path there are perhaps many more who are content with the perfunctory and the ritualistic as in the example of Soto Zen’s just sitting which is a function of ritual (J., gyoji).
.
Again I have to recommend these wonderful videos on zen buddhism/spirituality
(who is the guy making these pearls? Where does he get the material? I mean wow...)
I hope someone here might enjoy them as I have.
Paradise lost
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BYbv5pSZBM
(wonderful beautiful and awe-inspiring)
Spiritual prosperity
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Xy6ZBifcLM&feature=related
(deeply inspirational)
The Dharmakaya
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8mBthiGv6E&feature=related
(difficult to comprehend entirely but kindles something within oneself)
Posted by: azanshi | July 25, 2011 at 07:46 PM
Excellent post, right up to that last line. Given your clarity on this, it should be equally clear that "just sitting" can be an expression of the very weaning off religion you are talking about, or even a means of skipping all that entirely.
This is not a promotion/defense of Soto, as I am not a poractitioner. There is simply just somthing that strikes me as curious in your outright rejection of it.
Posted by: KGrey_Com | July 25, 2011 at 03:02 PM
Very good analysis of the religion vs. spirituality dilemma. The root word of religion is essentially “religare”, and it means to be “bound”. Essentially, many are bound and content with their “perfunctory and ritualistic” perception of their apparent spiritual reality. Yet, the comfort of samsara is rapidly unraveling in the ever shifting sands of this present dharma-ending age and many are becoming “rooted-out” of this complacency as the primordial spirit beckons them ever homeward.
Posted by: MStrinado | July 25, 2011 at 09:35 AM